Skip to content
Key takeaways
- The sunk cost fallacy in marketing keeps you stuck pouring money into failing campaigns because “you’ve already spent too much.”
- Stubbornly holding onto old strategies or tools wastes your budget when better options are out there.
- Stop the drain by using data, setting clear goals, and knowing when to cut losses.
Marketing can feel like a game of chance.
You pour time, money, and effort into campaigns that sometimes flop.
And then comes the sunk cost fallacy.
You’ve already spent so much…
So, you keep pushing ahead, hoping things will turn around.
Research even found this sunk cost trap popping up all over the place in all kinds of business decisions.
It’s an easy trap to fall into.
But if it’s eating up your budget, then it’s time to do something about it.
Here are five signs that the sunk cost fallacy is sabotaging your results — and what you can do to turn it around.
Signs that sunk cost fallacy in marketing is costing you big
Sign #1 — You’re bankrolling ads that just aren’t getting results
Ads can help you reach your business goals — but they can also be unpredictable.
Some campaigns go above and beyond.
Others? Total flop.
So why do so many marketers stick with underperforming ads, hoping for a sudden miracle?
Maybe you’ve spent hours refining your targeting, writing sharp copy, and designing eye-catching visuals.
But what if your CTR is miserable?
Or if conversions are practically nonexistent?
Throwing more money at the same thing is like setting your ads budget on fire.
The initial setup costs don’t matter once it’s live.
What matters now is how it performs.
So, watch real-time data closely.
Tweak where you can, like your keywords and your copy, for example.
But if it’s tanking, cut it quickly.
Don’t justify spending more just because of past effort.
Hoping a struggling ad will turn around after weeks of poor performance is wishful thinking.
Instead, shift your budget to A/B test other ideas.
Focus on what’s actually working — not on how much you’ve already sunk into a campaign.
Sign #2 — You’re ignoring what customers are saying because the “tried-and-true” feels easier
You’ve seen it happen.
Brands clinging to outdated strategies simply because they once struck gold.
Image ℅ Chicago Magazine
Sure, that email blast from 2018 had incredible open rates.
But times have changed.
The market has evolved.
Yet, some people still hang onto old tactics as though they’re biblical.
For example, maybe you’ve noticed your click-through rates on those email newsletters have tanked.
Instead of listening to what your customers are telling you (unsubscribes, low engagement, survey feedback), you stubbornly stick to what’s comfortable.
Simply because it worked before.
Basically, you’re throwing good money after bad.
People today are savvier than ever.
They expect personalisation and quick engagement.
They want to see you across all their favourite platforms.
So stop hoping that Myspace will make a comeback while everyone else is crushing it on TikTok.
If your audience is asking for something new, pay attention.
Otherwise, you’re just burning cash on outdated marketing that’s lost its edge.
Sign #3 — You’re pouring too much into a rebrand because it’s “exciting”
Yes, rebrands are exciting.
New logo, slick website, fresh colours — the full makeover.
You’ve brought in a branding agency, revamped everything, and launched with a bang.
But when that shiny new identity doesn’t connect with people?
Instead of rethinking the approach, lots of businesses panic.
They throw more money at ads, PR, and social media influencers — trying to force the rebrand to stick.
That’s the sunk cost fallacy in action.
Instead of recognising a misfire, you keep pushing, afraid to waste what you’ve already put in.
But here’s the hard truth…
No amount of promotion will save a rebrand that just doesn’t click.
If the data says it’s not working, pivot sooner rather than later.
Adjusting your strategy beats sinking more into a campaign that’s obviously not working.
It’s smart to tweak until it clicks.
Focus on connecting with people, not on justifying past investments.
Sign #4 — You hang on to clunky tools because setup wasn’t cheap
You invest in flashy software that’s supposed to change everything.
Then reality sets in.
It doesn’t.
But instead of cutting it loose, you keep paying for tools you barely touch — all because you’ve already spent time and money on them.
Sound familiar?
That’s the sunk cost fallacy at work.
Just because you trained your team or slogged through onboarding doesn’t mean you should keep paying something that’s not valuable.
Subscription fees add up fast.
Before you know it, your “savings tool” will turn into a budget drain.
So check in on your tech stack often.
Are these tools actually moving the needle?
Or just taking up space?
If they’re not adding value, let them go.
Don’t let onboarding struggles fool you into keeping something that isn’t giving you anything.
Sign #5 — You’re stuck on content that no one cares about anymore
Content marketing often falls prey to the sunk cost fallacy.
You pump out blogs, webinars, and whitepapers because they used to bring in leads.
But just because a format once worked doesn’t mean it still does.
Maybe blog posts were hitting hard a couple of years ago.
But now, people want videos, podcasts, and interactive experiences.
Clinging to outdated formats keeps you stuck while competitors adapt.
So what can you do?
Make it a habit to audit your digital marketing strategy.
Look at what’s actually driving traffic and conversions today.
If your blog series isn’t pulling leads anymore, stop pouring resources into it just out of habit.
Focus on what people need — not on what worked in the past.
How to kick the sunk cost fallacy out of your marketing
Basically, you need to stop tossing cash at things just because you’ve already sunk some into them.
Be ready to cut your losses and put your budget where it’ll actually deliver.
I get it — it’s easier said than done.
But here are a few steps that might help:
- Track your performance using real-time data
Don’t let last quarter’s stats keep a dead campaign on life support. Check your performance data regularly to see what’s actually bringing results today. If something’s slacking, don’t waste another dollar on it. Instead, shift that budget to something that’s still delivering the goods.
- Set crystal-clear goals from the get-go
Define exactly what success looks like for each project — whether it’s a target ROI, conversion rate, or engagement level. That way, you’ll know exactly when to pull the plug if things start going sideways. - Put someone on “reality check” duty
Assign a team member to play devil’s advocate and challenge assumptions. Their job? Ask the hard questions when a campaign isn’t pulling its weight. Having an outside perspective helps keep emotions and biases in check, so decisions are based on facts. - Always have an exit plan
Decide upfront when you’ll walk away — maybe after three months of underperformance or if specific marketing KPIs fall flat. Setting these “quit points” ahead of time keeps things objective when the going gets tough. This way, you’re less likely to cling to a campaign that’s clearly not working.
Sometimes, letting go is a power move
Good marketing isn’t about clinging to ideas just because you’ve spent time or money on them.
If returns aren’t stacking up, that’s your cue to pivot — not persevere.
Yes, dropping an investment might feel risky.
But it’s the kind of risk that frees up resources for ideas with real potential.
When you’re freeing up time, budget, and energy, you get the chance to pour them into something that can actually work.
Real progress comes from recognising when something has peaked so you can refocus on what’s next.
The sooner you learn to let go of what’s not working, the quicker you can shift to what does.
So, stop sticking with investments.
Instead, invest in what sticks.
